888-542-9002 Quotes@SelectAgency.com
FaceBook Button LinkedIn Button Twitter Button Google+ Button
Why settle when you can SELECT?

Our Mission

Select Agency is a family-owned business that has provided insurance to thousands of businesses for more than 20 years. Select's size is an asset, because the company can better manage accounts, enhance response time, and provide clients with direct access to the people they've come to know.

While Select Insurance provides the attention of a small company, its team is licensed to provide coverage in most U.S. states, coast-to-coast. Select provides coverage for thousands of domestic customers, and the company is a licensed agent for many "A" rated carriers.

Why Select Agency?

The owners of Select, Phillis MacDonald, and her son, Frank MacDonald, have maintained a policy which stipulates that every customer receives personal attention and policies that provide coverage for their unique risks. The representatives of Select interview their customers before developing insurance plans because, as the MacDonalds say, "Not every carrier is right for every customer."

Office Information

676A White Plains Road Scarsdale, NY 10583
Tel: 888-542-9002
Fax: 866-395-0200
Email Us: quotes@selectagency.com

Ken Unger

Ken Unger, president of family owned and operated Suburban Pest Control of New York, has been working with Select Insurance for 15 years.

“At the time, we were being grossly overcharged for auto, workers' compensation, liability and property insurance. Select has buying power because of its volume, and they were really able to help us. Frank and Phillis are good at managing problems that arise and are always there when you need them. Overall, I am very happy and would recommend them to anybody. They are very trustworthy, and you don't have to worry because you're covered from head to toe.”
Ken Unger, President
Suburban Pest Control of New York

Dave & Mary Paine

Dave and Mary Paine, co-owners of Dothan, Ala.-based All-Bama Inc. (dba Orkin), have been working with Select for four years

“I like how Frank MacDonald and the Select Insurance staff are available, by phone or email, every time I’ve contacted them — even for insignificant matters. A few years ago, we had an employee termination issue. We did not have employer’s practice insurance at the time, which was a relatively new type of insurance. Frank was instrumental in educating us and recommending a policy that would meet our needs, giving us the security in knowing that we were protected in the event of any future claim threats.”
Mary Paine, Co-Owner,
Orkin Pest Control Branch 906

Randy Abbitt

Randy Abbitt, president of family owned and operated National Exterminating Co. in Newport News, Va., has been working with Phillis at Select Insurance for more than 20 years.

“Phillis and I have a longstanding relationship. She is a wealth of knowledge and always has time to discuss how the pest control industry is doing and what direction we are going. She has been with us as we grew from a $650,000-a-year company to now more than $7 million annually. She has always made sure we are well protected and all our insurance needs are met to keep our company sound. The pricing has always been fair, and she and Frank are always available when I call.”
Randy Abbitt, President
National Exterminating Co. of Newport News

Joel Fagin

Floral Park, N.Y.-based Dial-A-Bug Pest Control, has been working with Select for nearly 25 years.

“Phillis and Frank are synonymous with reliability and trust. The timely fashion in which they answer our questions and provide us with needed documents is second to none. Our business has grown dramatically in the past 20 years, and it’s because we’ve always tried to surround ourselves with the best in the business for whatever our needs are. It’s no big secret that for insurance in our industry, it’s Select Insurance.”
Joel Fagin, Co-Owner

Joseph Sheehan

Brooklyn, N.Y.-based Colony Pest Management has been a Select Insurance customer from its start, 13 years ago

“Phillis and Frank are responsive, understand our industry and can be reached at any time. As our company has grown, they continue to advise us on what types of insurance we should have. One type — that I initially was not a fan of — was needed about 2 years after they said I needed it. Thankfully, I listened to them and we were fully covered!”
Joseph Sheehan, Principal

Joe Pestana

Joe Pestana, president of JP Pest Services, admits the company’s move to Select Insurance was more practical than anything else. “The company we were with was going bankrupt,” he says. “They were an offshore captive that suffered from mismanagement. We knew (Select Insurance Owner) Phillis MacDonald, and turned to her to provide the coverage we needed.”

“Phillis and Frank both understand our business — not only my business, but the industry as a whole. They give very good counsel on where our exposures are, and what we should have in place to protect our organization. They have my best interest at heart, and view our needs as the same needs they would have if it were their company.”
Joe Pestana, President,
JP Pest Services, Milford, N.H.